Terraria has spurred quite a bit of controversy over the short time it has been out. Some of you have probably seen this kind of review before about Terraria, so I’ll try to keep it a little short. The premise for all the conflict comes from the hardcore fans of Minecraft. Terraria is, quite honestly, a spinoff of Minecraft (although that doesn’t mean it plays the same, read below), and the fans have been abusing their keyboards about it ever since the game came out.
Terraria is a 2D game centered on exploring and creating things, in that order. A lot of the latter parts are very similar to Minecraft; of course, as to be expected as that game has pretty much defined the genre at this point. You start by cutting down trees (and goddamn swarms of slimes), which you use to craft tools and weapons, and build a house, get a family – and by that I mean NPCs like a merchant who sells you stuff that I have never needed after I got my first full set of armour. What primarily defines Terraria is its exploration and combat elements, particularly in the multiplayer aspect.
In short, Terraria had a huge edge on Minecraft when it comes to content. With one less dimension, things are much easier to just whip out on the fly. Terraria is, as a result, more detailed overall; FAR wider range of equipment to make/find, more biomes, and the maps are larger (vertically). It feels quite a bit like a RPG in this respect, especially with multiplayer. I got a server running (with quite little trouble, besides the infamous port forwarding catastrophe that I can now finally feast on its dead corpse for as long as possible) and had immense fun running about in caves with my friends as we shared loot that we find. You explore to find items only found exploring, building your character, which gives a broad feeling of progression and accomplishment. Also, let me say that the multiplayer works much, much smoother in Terraria, and PvP is an absolute blast.
If I could stop comparing Terraria to Minecraft for a moment, I have criticisms for it as a game. The amount of content is satisfactory, but I think that it’d be nice to have a bit further to go. I got max health and mana about three quarters through my career with a character, which although I think are at levels which would become ridiculous if they got higher, I just did it too quickly. There are bosses, which are fun, but there are only 3, and although at the moment I cannot solo them, it seems all my other friends can, and with others they become quite a breeze. Same goes with other events; the first blood moon I had was absolutely fantastic, mostly because it was with multiple people running around (throwing grenades, which now that I think about it was half the trouble with that encounter), but that was quite early game and I graduated that incredibly fast, and it’d be good to have other events that could challenge high levels.
You’re all probably waiting for my verdict: Which one is better? Well, I can’t answer. I’d say they both have their advantages, but to me I think Minecraft would last longer due to its wider range of possibilities. Of course, assuming the makers of Terraria can make content quickly, I imagine they could keep it fresh. But Terraria is much more fun as an action RPG than Minecraft, which isn’t a fair judgement to make since Minecraft is barely an action RPG at all. If I had to judge them on a common property, I’d say Minecraft has better creative prospects, although right now I am making a Castlevania like castle which I can’t really picture in Minecraft. This isn’t comparing two similar games, like Serious Sam and Duke Nukem. Which, by the way, has blown my mind that it is out. But that’s for another time.
They’re barely comparable to each other. Anyways, probably Monday I’ll have a bunch of new content to add. I’m going to be programming with Rory, so we should by then decide at least what engine we’re using for the project we have codenamed ‘Farblade’ for now. I should also be able to link to a pair of music videos I acted in, and sometime next week I’ll be able to post the music video I wrote, directed, and edited, realised was crap, re-wrote, re-directed and re-edited.
Interested in joining my Terraria or Minecraft server? Contact me in real life and I’ll let you in, although Minecraft is ruled by a council who all must approve of the joining.